Tractor Supply Rubber Stall Mat vs. FlooringInc 3/4" Rubber Gym Tiles
Not that
3/4" Premium Gym Floor Tiles, Vulcanized Rubber (4' x 6', Black)
FlooringInc
$93.95
Same 3/4 inch of rubber. The stall mats run $2.67 a square foot against $4.45 for the tiles. For a garage you'll drop weights in, keep the difference.
You keep $29.96.
Prices checked October 27, 2026. Rubber Stall Mat, 4 ft. x 6 ft. x 3/4 in. in stock at Tractor Supply Co. as of October 27, 2026 (stock varies by store; check yours).
Why the coach picked it
- Cost per square foot: $2.67 for the stall mat ($63.99 / 24 sq ft) vs. $4.45 for the tile on sale. That's 40% less for the same 3/4" thickness.
- For a 12 x 20 ft one-car bay, ten stall mats cover 240 sq ft for $639.90. The same area in tiles is about $1,068 at the sale price, before rounding up to whole tiles.
- Both are vulcanized recycled rubber. Your deadlift doesn't know which one has the nicer name.
- You can pick stall mats up at the store. The black 4' x 6' tiles showed a Nov 24 to Dec 17 ship window today.
- Each mat is 94 lb vs. about 105 lb per tile. Still bring a friend and a utility knife.
When the other one is the right call
If the gym shares space with a finished room, or you want colors and snap-together seams with no glue, buy the FlooringInc tiles. You're paying for a cleaner-looking floor.
Side by side
| Rubber Stall Mat, 4 ft. x 6 ft. x 3/4 in. | 3/4" Premium Gym Floor Tiles, Vulcanized Rubber (4' x 6', Black) |
|---|
| Price per piece | $63.99 (4 x 6 ft mat) | $93.95 (4 x 6 ft tile, sale) |
|---|
| Coverage per piece | 24 sq ft | 21.09 sq ft interlocked |
|---|
| Cost per sq ft | $2.67 | $4.45 (sale; $6.85 compare-at) |
|---|
| Thickness | 3/4 in | 3/4 in |
|---|
| Weight per piece | 94 lb | About 105 lb |
|---|
| Material | 100% recycled vulcanized rubber | Vulcanized recycled rubber (color versions add EPDM flecks at 25% color density) |
|---|
| Interlocking | No | Yes, snap-together, no glue |
|---|
Where these facts come from